83

See who gave your art a 'try' #24

Feature Resolved
Amstel Amstel · opened

I really love the 'try' feature, but it'd be cool if it was expanded a bit:

  • See WHO gave your idea a try
  • See what original someone's art was based on, if they used the 'try' feature on someone's work.

Resolved: Dreams made with Try show who inspired them, and "Tried by" next to Try shows who tried yours.

Merged into this report 4

The same thing, reported separately. Their votes and comments count here now, and the people who filed them hear about every answer.

  • #31 author of the original image

    Pierre D. Pierre D. · filed · merged

    I don't know if this has already been requested, but would it be possible to automatically add the name of the original image author when a "Try It" is performed ?

    Same request as #24: credit the original author when someone uses Try. Votes and comments moved there.

  • #91 When someone tries someone's prompt, you should see who is trying it. The originator should automatically get credit.

    Sinomine Sinomine · filed · merged

    Same request as #24: see who tried your dream and credit the original author. Votes and comments moved there.

  • #107 Add a default-on checkbox that grants credit when publishing a dream

    Varia Varia · filed · merged

    Have a checkbox enabled by default that grants credit. Those who don't want to give credit would have to actively uncheck it. If someone uses copy-paste, they'll likely miss the modifiers and any negative prompt that might be included. Publishing a "dream" without credit would then reveal something about the person running the generation. That would, at the very least, eliminate some of the laziness behind not giving credit.

    Now part of #24: with Try, credit to the original is on by default and shows as "Inspired by". Remove it before generating if you do not want it.

  • #133 To see directly who used me in the dream.

    israel israel · filed · merged

    I’d love an option where, whenever someone "uses" you in a dream, I can see who it is—instead of having to guess by searching for that image.

    Same request as #24: seeing who tried your dream. It is now done: look for "Tried by" next to Try on your dream.

55 comments

  • Evelyn Kate
    Evelyn Kate

    OHH yes that would be greatly appreciated! That's something I've always wished

  • Amstel
    Amstel

    I already requested that in my 'See who gave your art a try' feature request: "See what original someone's art was based on, if they used the 'try' feature on someone's work." Please upvote that one! :)

  • ⚡Velyrion
    ⚡Velyrion

    I second that request. Makes absolutely sense to me.

  • Amstel
    Amstel

    Please upvote this request, they might do something with it! ;)

  • Pierre D.
    Pierre D.

    I hadn't seen it. Thanks, Amstel, I've voted.

  • Xymo Nau
    Xymo Nau

    I think it needs to be the genuinely original artist if they have tried a try.

  •  *™Mellissa*/AI Art
    *™Mellissa*/AI Art

    Yes, i want to see who tried

  • Fearless Leader ☠
    Fearless Leader ☠

    Agreed 👍

  • Fearless Leader ☠
    Fearless Leader ☠

    Question... what if i "try" a dream, then use the magic wand the prompt?

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Having clicked Try It it can be very useful to modify aspects of prompt before generating - how much alteration would be appropriate before one's generation took over as a New Dream to then be available for Try It? If quite different to the image one had started from by Trying It, it wouldn't be appropriate if the original artist continued to be credited down the line.

  • Beate Vogl
    Beate Vogl

    Genau das fehlt mir auch. Dann kann man feststellen, wer die Prompts einfach kopiert.

  • Petr
    Petr

    It would be perfect if the signatures of all the original contributing authors were automatically added to the final image—it would save me so much work manually listing the lineage of "my" image! It would be even better if the same applied to the base images used. My only concern is whether there would be any room left for the actual image itself, given all those signatures...;-)

  •  *™Mellissa*/AI Art
    *™Mellissa*/AI Art

    Yes yes please, I also sent emails, certain big dreamers tent to copy and not mention, seeing my prompt( dream) on the front page.yet no mention

  • Debbie Eh?
    Debbie Eh?

    Maybe automatically add the comment "Image is based on a "Try" of <image address of original dream>". Then people can visit and like the original if they want to.

  • Santana
    Santana

    Oh yes yes yes

  •  Monarchalex
    Monarchalex

    Да, очень интересно посмотреть кто попробовал и что получилось.

  •  Monarchalex
    Monarchalex

    Я за, если авторы исходников будут добавляться автоматически

  • SiouX
    SiouX

    YESSSS

  • Fausto
    Fausto

    si si, concordo

  • Fausto
    Fausto

    è una ottima idea. Sarebbero annullati tutti quegli pseudo-creatori che si prendono guadagni quotidiani, anche sostanziosi, a copiare immagini e prompt ideati dai bravi autori

  • Xymo Nau
    Xymo Nau

    I agree. With many of my images I spend a lot of points, and then someone comes along and copies and pastes my prompt, changes it slightly, and can get 200 points from an editor's choice, or at least points from tries on their result, after I have spent all of those points to get there. A credit gives me nothing, but acknowledgement at least might encourage others to use the original try as well.

  • Sorrah
    Sorrah

    Exactly. I agree 100%

  • Kester Pelagius
    Kester Pelagius

    Or a link back via thumbnail of the original "Try" image.

  • Kirsten Wilson
    Kirsten Wilson

    Yes totally agree! Since I have started joining in and interacting with the community, checking out galleries, I have tried and remixed a couple of prompts and gave manual credit with one in Deep Dream when I published the art and the other I credited in picsart where I published that art. It would be much easier to have an auto attachment.

  • Liz F
    Liz F

    I agree, and also if you try someone's prompt, it should be easy to find from whom you got the prompt. I have spent a lot of time trying to find where I got the original prompt. Some are obvious, but if you like a lot of pictures, you may not remember which artist you did a try-it on. If you're doing this from a phone or a tablet, you have to remember to manually write their name down because it's really hard to find after the fact. I try the search feature using the most pertinent part of the prompt, but the search feature in DDG is really bad. You get a thousand pictures, many of them totally unrelated to what you typed in. Just a quick link-back would be nice.

  • gisella
    gisella

    i agree

  • Annie
    Annie

    i agree also.. i am guilty of this as i cant remember where the prompt came from...so I can give them credit,,

  • Yvain de Leonais
    Yvain de Leonais

    Personally, I would at least offer a checkbox allowing the user to choose whether the other person sees that I’ve created a "try" based on their idea, and I would include a notification saying, "User XYZ has created a 'Dream try it' based on yours."
    Please keep in mind that not every "try it" is successful or even gets published.
    In other words, you have a responsibility regarding how you handle that information and must avoid "bothering" the other person (sorry, I can't phrase it any better—I'm not a native speaker/writer).
    Additionally, a second checkbox might be handy to automatically fill in the source—i.e., the Dream and/or the original creator (the other user)—when I use the "Try it" feature.
    With the checkboxes, everyone would have a choice rather than facing an automatic requirement—something that might otherwise deter "dreamers" from clicking the "Try it" button.

  • Amstel
    Amstel

    Already requested #24. Please upvote that one too!

  • Amstel
  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Often a Try It prompt is modified substantially before clicking to actually activate the Try It. How could it be decided how much alteration would deem it to be a new prompt? A bit of a minefield!

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    I think modifying the current setup could actually deter many users from using DDG rather than other AI generators.

  • Susanne
    Susanne

    A very very good idea. I agree 100%

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Whilst I can see why people want this, I suspect less people would then use Try It (which could be detrimental to DDG's popularity). Could also mean less credit received by people using one's prompts via Try It.

  •  *™Mellissa*/AI Art

    Yes! Ok it's not hard to copy and paste or use the magicwand, but here is alot of dreamers that try as is and still nit mention where they got it, instead slapping their name on. So I would like to see how my dream was used or changed. Or atleast just show who tried

  • Amstel
    Amstel

    @Unreal: But why? Why would people care if the original author of a prompt was named? I wouldn't mind for sure. Also, personally I wouldn't score based on whether it was someone's original prompt or not.

  • LILLY
    LILLY

    This is honestly one of the reasons I haven't invested much time in building a following here. I've seen that many people use my images as a base for their own versions — but I rarely get to see where they end up. Once, by pure chance, I stumbled on a result made from one of my images, and I was a little taken aback: it had so many likes and comments, while I'd gotten just a single like from it. 😅 It made me think that maybe there should be more visibility around the fact that a published image is built on someone else's original prompt. it's a reason why I am not motivating enough to make me want to be here, engage, or spend money on a subscription.

  • Boggart
    Boggart

    💯👍

  • Sinomine
    Sinomine

    @LILLY, you totally nailed it. Imagine working so hard on a prompt, you post it - maybe you're luck to get a few likes. Then someone "Tries" it, and they got tons of likes. It makes no sense. There are so many ways to get around it. Many platforms offer a "Remix" feature and it always ties back to the originator of the prompt. If you end up changing the prompt so much that it barely resembles the original, the system will say it's no longer a Remix. Now it's your own image. How hard is it to implement that? Not hard at all.

  • Deborah Register
    Deborah Register

    Do we all pay yo be here?

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    I think it's more complicated than that. I f one has made substantial alterations to a try it prompt, (or crucially, used a guide image of one's own making), then it can be much more one's creation than the agitator of the try it author. Having said that when I do a straightforward try it, I do usually credit the prompts author if I can still recall or check who it was!

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Originator not agitator!!

  •  *™Mellissa*/AI Art

    Just to add, I go on certain big dreamers profile and see one of my dreams, but they modify the prompt so much but the results are so the same as my dream, and then they have the ordasity to say don't take his name out of it but the dream got 200 like and 20 comments but its a dream they did not even think about they just went sbd changed the wording so much that it looks like their creation and you can't pin point, so this whole page is full of pirates.

  • JadeCyberNZ Landscapes & Wildlife

    I agree. That's why every time I try someone's prompt, I put the username, image name and link in the top of the description of the generated image to give credit to that user.

  • Alma Lee
    Alma Lee

    This is my number one time suck. I tend to run a batch of prompts and then have no room to share or I haven't decided if I want it puplic yet. Often times I see something in my image that I never saw before and decide you know I like that but because I did not publish it at the time shortly before moving on. sometimes let months and months past and I still have no Idea where or from who I got the prompt from.

  • Jessica  Miller
    Jessica Miller

    i'd like to know who tries a prompt

  • Varia
    Varia

    @Alma Lee when i do a try and don't want to publish it yet. I cope paste name creator and adres dream and click edit info and paste it in the titel section, so i wil remember who and where it came from.

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Using a prompt plus adjustments, or a section of a prompt, makes a user no more of a "pirate" than anyone using a base image they did not produce from scratch themselves! If one cannot derive ideas from others then all AI art would be impossible - the entire concept relies on the AI gathering together what innumerable other creators have done over centuries, together with everything being created today both manually and electronically. So no one is a 'Pirate' unless everyone using AI is! And no AI creation would be a great loss.

  • Petr
    Petr

    Jessica, when someone tries out another person's prompt, they usually "like" it around the same time; if the resulting image turns out well, they publish it. You simply have to look at the work of those who liked the image at the moment you get inspiration point. It’s such a lovely, adventurous quest—and yet so many people want to spoil it! ;-))

  • Xymo Nau
    Xymo Nau

    Unreal, in the world of copyright, you can't claim copyright on an image you have used and changed unless the original is unrecognisable. Until the base is unrecognisable, then I think a credit is reasonable. Because often, even if the colours and a few other things are changed, the bones of the original image - the whole reason for trying it - are still there.

  • Varia
    Varia

    that request is already made.
    https://deepdreamgenerator.com/feedback/24

  •  *™Mellissa*/AI Art

    I'm not saying you are doing it, but you speak like someone who is comfortable trying other people's prompts without giving recognition or mentioning where you got it from. Why is it an issue for you to give credit? We share prompts to see who tries them and to support each other.

    Taking someone else's prompt word-for-word and putting your name on it is copywriting and piracy.

    Under Copyright Law:
    1. Original works are protected. According to the U.S. Copyright Act 17 U.S.C. § 102 and the Berne Convention, any original literary work, including a detailed and creative written prompt, is automatically protected by copyright the moment it is written.
    2. Copying without permission is infringement. 17 U.S.C. § 501 states that copying, reproducing or claiming someone else's original work as your own without permission is copyright infringement.
    3. Credit does not erase theft. Giving no credit, or just changing one word, does not make it yours. That is still plagiarism and piracy.

    I tend to think out my own dreams, I don't try to copy others. My images come from my own head, my own heart, and my own words. I create from scratch — I don't need to take from someone else. Please respect that and respect all creators here. A simple credit costs nothing.

  • Sinomine
    Sinomine

    @™Mellissa/AI Art, well said and totally agree. People who steal other peoples ideas and don't give the originator credit are selfish and without etiquette. I'm reading a lot of excuses here for not giving the original creator their due. If you can't give credit to the originator -- who supplied you with the idea based on their hard work and their own imagination, then come up with your own ideas. Do the work: be creative, use your imagination, study great art, learn about art history, composition, color theory. If you can't do that, then maybe you shouldn't be generating images.

  •  *™Mellissa*/AI Art

    @Sinomine yes I don't understand what's the argue, and why this and that. Just have the decency to give recognition, or don't generate images if you can't think for yourself.

  • DDG
    DDG

    Done! A dream made with Try now shows "Inspired by" with the author of the original (and "originally by …" when it was a Try of a Try).

    On your own dream, "Tried by" next to Try lists everyone who published something made with it. Tries kept private are only counted, never named.

    Every Try is now recorded when the image is saved, and we went back through older tries and recovered about 500,000 of them. More in the release notes: https://deepdreamgenerator.com/updates

Log in to join in.