Who's Left Outside? - Diversity Saturday

55
4
  • Emiliano Girina's avatar Artist
    Emiliano G...
  • DDG Model
    ChatGPT 2
  • Mode
    Pro
  • Access
    Public
  • Created
    11h ago
  • Try Try style

Prompt

Korean manhwa webtoon illustration, semi-realistic, with clean refined linework, soft cel shading, delicate color gradients and highly detailed facial expressions and body language. The image is split vertically into two panels of equal width with strong mirrored symmetry. Left panel in warm sepia, faded brown and amber tones, like an old memory: a worn plaster wall with a rectangular enamel sign showing a large solid white disc followed by the word "ONLY" in bold black capital letters, above a closed restroom door marked with a male pictogram. In front of the door stand a Black man in a dark brown work shirt, shoulders squared and arms held stiffly at his sides, jaw clenched, brow furrowed, eyes narrowed with restrained anger and quiet dignity as he glances sideways at the sign; beside him a Black woman in a plain beige short-sleeved dress with her hair pulled back in a bun, one hand gripping her other wrist in front of her, shoulders slightly drawn in, lips pressed tight, eyes heavy with weariness and humiliation held back. Right panel in brighter cream, ivory and soft beige tones, a contemporary setting with an identical composition: a modern rectangular sign showing the male symbol ♂ and the female symbol ♀ side by side followed by the word "ONLY" in bold black capital letters, and next to them the transgender symbol ⚧ crossed out with a red diagonal line, above a closed restroom door marked with a female pictogram; pinned to the wall beside the door frame, a small white printed notice sheet with a strip of tape at the top, bearing in neat black type the date "311º 2026 CE", like an official posting date. In front of the door stand a Black woman with a natural curly afro and hoop earrings wearing a tank top with light blue, pink and white horizontal stripes, chin slightly raised, steady unblinking gaze straight at the viewer, posture upright and grounded, expressing calm defiance; next to her a young white man with light brown hair wearing a denim jacket over a white shirt with pink stripes, standing half a step closer to her in a quietly protective stance, eyebrows slightly lifted, a mix of hurt and resolve in his eyes; and a young East Asian woman with a straight black bob wearing a light blue t-shirt with pink and white stripes, hands curled into loose fists at her sides, lower lip pressed, eyes glossy but determined, holding back tears without looking away. The emotional echo between the two panels is carried by mirrored poses and gazes, subtle and restrained rather than theatrical. Sharp legible symbols and lettering on both signs and on the notice, cinematic soft lighting, landscape format. Small elegant calligraphic signature in the bottom right corner reading "Milo".

More about Who's Left Outside? - Diversity Saturday

Two doors, two eras, one logic.

On the left, a memory in sepia: a sign that once decided who could enter by the color of their skin. A man stands with his jaw clenched, a woman grips her own wrist, both holding back what they cannot say. On the right, a present-day door with a different sign and the same message: you are not expected here. Three people look straight at us, not with rage, but with a quiet, steady question.

I do not believe the division of restrooms and changing rooms into men and women was born of malice. It has a real function, the protection of privacy and safety, and for the vast majority of people it works. But it is a historical and approximate criterion: sex-specific public restrooms largely date back to the Victorian era. And it leaves a minority without a clear place: people with variations of sex development, whose estimated frequency ranges from about 0.018% to 1.7% depending on the definition, and people who identify outside the binary, estimated at between 0.3% and 4.5% of adults. They are minorities, yet in a country like Italy they number in the hundreds of thousands.

I keep sex, gender and sexual orientation carefully apart. This is about something simpler: having somewhere to go.

I am not fighting separation in itself. My principle is that no one should be left without a space where they can be safe and dignified. The criterion I use to decide which needs deserve accommodation is the absence of alternatives, like a ramp for a wheelchair user: without it, there is no access. For those who do not fit either pole, today the only choice is often a space where they risk rejection or harassment; trans people report more verbal harassment in restrooms matching the sex assigned at birth than in those matching their identity.

So I am not asking to abolish anything overnight. In a first phase, I propose adding a well-designed universal space next to the existing ones: fully enclosed individual stalls, changing rooms with private cubicles and individual showers, shared areas such as sinks visible from outside. This is not a utopia: in Denmark and Sweden, unisex public restrooms are already ordinary. Only later, in one or two generations, would it make sense to ask whether separation can be reduced. If it does not work, or the time is not right, we wait and keep the third space. I reject the idea of one space for every shade of gender and sex: it would be impractical, and it would end up marking and dividing people instead of including them. No solution is perfectly neutral; I choose the one that, in my judgment, minimizes exclusion.

Change should not be imposed; it should be taught. I would like future generations to receive civic and relationship education that teaches respect for bodies and for other people's boundaries, as we once learned to think differently about secularism, disability and minority rights. I am not asking anyone to expose their body: architecture exists precisely for that. What I would like to dissolve is shame of the body as a negative judgment, which I see as a cultural residue more than a necessity. Privacy and shame are not the same thing, and only the second needs to fade.

The question this image asks is not "which door?", but "who is left outside?"

Comments


Loading Dream Comments...

Discover more dreams from this artist