73

Add area selection for AI edits in the new editor, like the old editor had #82

Feature Resolved
Yvain de Leonais Yvain de Leonais · opened ·from chat

Please implement a feature in the new AI editor that lets us select specific areas for changes, like in the old editor. The AI tends to alter things all over the image—especially elements I didn't even ask to be changed.

In the meantime, could the energy costs in the new editor be reduced? You end up wasting so many energy points because the AI fails to make the desired changes; instead, it ruins the image or sometimes completely transforms it into something else entirely. Or please release a manual, how-to guide, or set of instructions for the editor. I wasted a lot of energy in the editor again today without getting anything usable out of it, and it is incredibly frustrating.

Resolved: Select area in the AI Image Editor: paint the part to change, and only that part changes.

Merged into this report 1

The same thing, reported separately. Their votes and comments count here now, and the people who filed them hear about every answer.

  • #105 Mask Editor

    Kenneth Sno Kenneth Sno · filed · merged

    A mask editor would allow you to isolate specific areas of an image so you can highlight, emphasize, or adjust only that selected portion.

    Same request as #82: select an area of the image and edit only that part.

14 comments

  • Zorax
    Zorax

    Excellent idea, I support 100%.

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Yes , it wouldn't need to be an accurate selection as the old editor required - just an indicator of which feature one's text referred to. Naturally an precise selection might make the AI more precise too!

  • Leann
    Leann

    I wholeheartedly agree. It would give us the ability to fine tune minute changes, instead of altering the whole appearance of the image, the art we are trying to bring to life.

  • Rainer Warzecha
    Rainer Warzecha

    good idea, this would be true improvement!

  • Chiptrees
    Chiptrees

    That's a great idea—it really would be nice to add more tools specifically for manual image editing. Some of the results have minor glitches, but they're noticeable and ruin the image. So I'm still stuck with the clunky old editor for now.

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Another thought - If one had several things one was asking AI editor to improve/remove maybe when marking them manually one could label those 1, 2, 3 etc and refer to that numbering in ones instructions.

  • Unreal
    Unreal

    Oh yes, HDR would be nice in a more manual editor. Don't think it's on DDG currently?

  • pat haney
    pat haney

    Agree, this would be great…

  • mofaha
    mofaha

    worth taking a look at inpainting, some of the things you mention here are achievable with it

  • Kenneth Sno
    Kenneth Sno

    Inpainting is nothing like a true mask editor.

  • Nori
    Nori

    Sounds very interesting. I think I would support all of these suggestions and I do agree with (hang on, who said this?) Chiptrees, and Kenneth Sno.

  • mofaha
    mofaha

    @Kenneth Sno That's true Ken, but some of the things mentioned here are definitely achievable with inpainting along with some thoughtful prompting. I was suggesting a different path, not a full alternative.

  • Yvain de Leonais
    Yvain de Leonais

    @mofaha
    Yeah, maybe, but it’s really a gamble; often nothing happens, or the opposite occurs, or the AI ​​inserts or changes things inappropriately during inpainting. Plus, the edits are often clearly visible because they stand out from the rest of the image.
    The new AI editor, on the other hand, often alters the entire image—changing things everywhere and anywhere—despite what should be a precise prompt. It doesn't have to work exactly like inpainting; having a frame to draw around the specific area where the AI ​​editor should operate—and exclude areas outside that frame—would be extremely desirable. Especially since a failed attempt where the AI ​​botches the image costs 50 energy instead of just 4 Energie, and there’s no refund system either.

  • DDG
    DDG

    Done! In the AI Image Editor, choose Select area in the toolbar on your image and paint over the part you want to change (with an eraser, brush size and undo). Then write your prompt and press Edit Image: only the painted area changes, and everything else stays exactly as it was. It works with every model. More in the release notes: https://deepdreamgenerator.com/updates

Log in to join in.