Barbarella & The Robots (Nano Banana Pro)

More about Barbarella & The Robots (Nano Banana Pro)

Comparison of the same prompt across the new image models

7. Barbarella & The Robots (Nano Banana Pro)

This concludes the new model comparison experiment and now the results and marks achieved by the various models. Remember this is my opinion only and based on this one prompt.

1. Z-Image Turbo - looks like a film still, woman is very lifelike. However looks nothing like Jane Fonda's Barbarella and the pistol in her hand is clearly wrong. Also Jim Starlin on the prompt was a comic book artist and I don't see any of his influence here 3/10

2. QWEN - Feels a little more comic book like, Barbarella is actually holding a nice looking pistol. However some of the robots in the background are incomplete and wrong looking. Once again the woman looks nothing like Jane Fonda's Barbarella. 3/10

3. SeeDream - first impression great image. The robots look great, Barbarella is holding a cool pistol, nice motion blur. The woman looks nothing like Jane Fonda's Barbarella and there is no hit of comic book in the image. It looks more like a still from a Sci-Fi action movie 6/10

4. ImagineArt - Not a fan of this image. Its similar in many ways to the Z-Image Turbo one, but slightly better drawn. Looks nothing like Barbarella and no hint of comic book 4/10

5. ChatGPT - first impression is that this is nothing special and similar to SeeDream. The robots look fine (I like that they are not identical), Barbarella is holding a boring pistol, nice motion blur. the woman looks nothing like Jane Fonda's Barbarella and there is no hit of comic book in the image. It looks more like a still from a Sci-Fi action movie 6/10

6. Flux2 - First impression is very good! Great robots, very cool pistol, hint of motion blur. Barbarella is very well drawn. But again no feel of the comic book artist. would make a great movie (maybe I'll generate a video from this) 7.5/10

7. Nano Banana Pro - First impression, wow! Looks amazingly like Jane Fonda's Barbarella (at last!). Barb has a cool pistol. Robots are not too exciting but fit well with the retrofuturistic part of the prompt. Best of all is that the whole image is a perfect blend of film still & comic book. This is pretty close to perfect... 10/10

Conclusion: Based on this limited test, Nano Banana Pro is best at following your prompt instructions. The quality of the image output also seems extremely high.