Comments
Loading Dream Comments...
You must be logged in to write a comment - Log In
Fantasy landscape in blue and white colors, forest, mountains, in the style of Roger Dean.
(Double LP, gatefold, 1977; original pressing includes fold-out "map" with no scale)
Side A — Ascent
A Moon Too Near for Naming — 8:46
White Fern, Black Water — 6:11
The Mountains Remember Upward — 12:03
Side B — Correspondence
Where the Valley Becomes Thought — 7:31
Three Trees Against Eternity — 5:44
The Lake Beneath the Other Sky — 9:18
Side C — Interior Cartography
No Kingdom Has Claimed This — 6:39
Blue Distance, Blue Return — 11:26
The Pilgrim Misplaces the Horizon — 4:57
Side D — Arrival
The Road That Needed No Traveller — 7:08
Moonrise Over the Interior — 10:14
The Blue Between Worlds — 5:02
Melody Maker Review (1977)
THE BLUE BETWEEN WORLDS
Artist: Pilgrim’s Measure
Label: Meridian Glass
★★★★☆
There comes a point in every progressive rock band’s career when somebody looks at a
mountain and decides it is withholding doctrine.
Pilgrim’s Measure have reached that point and, on The Blue Between Worlds, appear
determined to extract the doctrine at album length.
The gatefold depicts an impossible blue valley beneath a moon of reckless proportions.
Inside are two records, six pages of lyrics, a diagram titled THE CORRESPONDENCE OF
HEIGHTS, and a production credit for “atmospheric perspective.” Bassist Adrian Wale is
credited, without comment, with “terrestrial patience.”
The record is magnificent.
This is not to say it is sensible.
“A Moon Too Near for Naming” begins with wind, temple bells and a twelve-string figure so
delicate one suspects the microphone was instructed not to frighten it. Mellotron and choir
arrive by degrees until the band have apparently decided the moon is not a satellite but a
question. No answer is provided.
“The Mountains Remember Upward” spends twelve minutes arguing that vertical geology
possesses memory. Guitarist Stephen Zale plays perhaps forty notes. Each arrives with the
solemnity of a stone tablet descending from cloud cover.
Side B is less accommodating.
“Where the Valley Becomes Thought” includes the lyric:
No foot has named the path below;
Yet every height remembers snow.
A flute solo in 11/8 follows. Whether these facts are related is unclear.
“Three Trees Against Eternity” is five minutes of bass harmonics, brushed cymbals and
Mellotron choir devoted, apparently, to three trees standing on a ridge. Against expectation,
the trees win.
“The Lake Beneath the Other Sky” begins as a pastoral instrumental and ends with what
sounds like seventeen monks drowning slowly in reverb.
Side C is where Pilgrim’s Measure cease pretending this is music in the conventional sense
and begin treating the stereo field as sacred topography. “Blue Distance, Blue Return”
contains two chords, one synthesizer note, and an eleven-minute migration from left speaker
to right. The sleeve notes describe the movement as “the listener crossing himself.”
Critics will call this indulgent. Critics will be correct.
It is also, maddeningly, beautiful.
What saves the album from collapsing beneath its own robes is that Pilgrim’s Measure never
seem to be joking. There is no wink beneath the wizard sleeves. If they believe a mountain
can possess inwardness, a road can predate the traveller, or blue can function as a
metaphysical condition, then by God they have hired enough analogue equipment to test the
hypothesis properly.
“The Road That Needed No Traveller” proceeds for six minutes without drums, modulation, or
evidence of human impatience. “Moonrise Over the Interior” repeatedly threatens to become
a rock song, then withdraws into organ chords vast enough to have weather.
The title track is the shortest piece and the most dangerous. It begins with the four-note
guitar phrase heard on Side A, now slowed almost beyond recognition. Instruments enter one
at a time, not building toward climax but toward stillness. The final chord hangs unresolved
long enough for the listener to suspect resolution was a provincial expectation all along.
Then the record stops.
No gong. No prophecy. No returning choir. One hears tape hiss, then nothing.
What is The Blue Between Worlds about? Another planet? Mystical geography? Death?
Reincarnation? The inability of language to survive contact with sufficient scenery? A walking
holiday in Wales after somebody found unusually strong mushrooms?
Pilgrim’s Measure have declined to say. Their silence may be the album’s most coherent
statement.
This is pompous music, certainly, but its pomposity contains a strange humility. The band do
not claim to explain the landscape. They merely behave as if it deserves ninety minutes, two
discs, a choir, three synthesizers and your complete surrender of proportion.
By the end, one is no closer to understanding the valley. One has merely become
embarrassed for having expected it to explain itself.
Recommended for headphones, impossible moons, and anyone prepared to entertain the
possibility that mountains are not symbols of anything and nevertheless judging you.